Bookman: Welcome to Bleorgia

Drawings of Democratic Donkey and Republican Elephant on opposite sides of a purple drawing of the State of Georgia

by Jay Bookman, Georgia Recorder, [This article first appeared in the Georgia Recorder, republished with permission]

November 19, 2026

Is Georgia now blue?

With every statewide office in the hands of Democrats, you’d probably have to say yes. And while the abruptness of the transformation has been stunning, it’s also true that it has been coming for a long time. The signs were there.

For example, you now have to go back an entire decade, to 2016, to find the last time a Republican won a U.S. Senate race in Georgia. Since then, Democrats have won four consecutive Senate races, two by Raphael Warnock and two by Jon Ossoff. The first two were extremely close, but the margins grew in the more recent two, with Ossoff putting a cherry on top by winning his re-election race by 18 percentage points. 

As they say in the sports world, you are what your record says you are. And the record says we’re blue.

You also have to consider that Joe Biden carried the state in 2020, and while Donald Trump won it narrowly in 2024, I doubt even the most optimistic Georgia Republican would put big money on winning the state’s 16 electoral votes in 2028. It’s just hard to imagine the trend line reversing so quickly.

So for the state Republican Party, it’s time to stare into a mirror and be honest about what you see. How did you get here, and what do you do next? If your spouse has left you, your kids won’t talk to you, you lost your job and the mortgage is past due, what now? 

Do you keep doing what got you in this situation, or do you alter course?

They got in this predicament because the state of Georgia and the state Republican Party have both changed significantly in the last decade, but they’ve changed in different directions. 

While the state has grown more diverse and less conservative, the state GOP has done the opposite. Instead of making peace with that diversity, instead of embracing it and adapting to it, Georgia Republicans have used it to fuel a backlash against such changes. 

That strategy worked, for a while, and in large parts of the state it still does. Those GOP state legislators who survived the midterm debacle did so because they represent districts that remain deep red to this day, so they may not feel pressured to alter course. 

But in statewide races such as a U.S. Senate campaign, that strategy does not work and never will again. The demographic changes have simply become too profound to overcome: Every voter they win by advocating an aggressive anti-immigrant platform, for example, is offset by two voters who they drive away with that policy.

Look at the Mike Collins campaign for Senate. He took a hardcore, juice-the-base MAGA strategy that ought to work well in his deep-red home congressional district – a district that Trump won by 21 points – then used it as a blueprint from which to run a statewide campaign. 

He lost by more than 700,000 votes. 

The details are even more damning. Even though Collins sat at the top of the ballot, he got 200,000 fewer votes than the Republican candidate for agriculture commissioner. That means even Republican voters went out of their way to reject him and his message. His performance was so bad that he won his own deep-red 10th District by less than a percentage point. Two years ago, he had won re-election in that district by 26 points.

So blue state or not, Georgia is not a MAGA state. In fact, you could even argue that it never was. Our last Republican senator, the one we elected a decade ago, was the late Johnny Isakson, a moderate who today’s GOP base would run off as a RINO. Our three most recent Republican governors, Sonny Perdue, Nathan Deal and Brian Kemp, were all conservative, and were all re-elected to second terms, but none of them governed in the MAGA fashion.

If Republicans fear that Democrats are going to do real harm to the state, they need to become competitive again as quickly as possible. That process begins by understanding that the Georgia they once knew no longer exists, because the people of this state have decided it shouldn’t. 

Georgia Recorder is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Georgia Recorder maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Jill Nolin for questions: info@georgiarecorder.com.