By John A. Tures, Professor of Political Science, LaGrange College
A year ago, my son treated me to my first Monday Night Football Game. The Atlanta Falcons took on one of the best teams in the National Football Conference (NFC), a Los Angeles Rams team that would make it to the conference finals. In an epic battle, the Falcons, led by Bijan Robinson and Kirk Cousins, jumped out to an early lead, and held on for a 27-24 win.
Almost a year later, the Rams are still poised for another playoff run behind former UGA QB Star Matthew Stafford, who won the NFL MVP Award. Meanwhile, Cousins was traded away to the Las Vegas Raiders. Now he’s traveling to the Minnesota Vikings a good team with a bad quarterback situation. The Vikings could make their first Super Bowl since the 1970s with Cousins. Meanwhile, the Falcons are once again set for a losing record, with a below average QB in Michael Pennix, and far worse play from others like Tua Tagovailoa and Cooper Rush.
Does a quarterback really mean so much to the National Football League? Would the Falcons benefit from drafting or trading for a good QB, or should they focus more on other positions of need, trading a draft pick to get several picks to rebuild the roster?
To teach my undergraduate students about non-parametric analyses, we ran a Chi-Square test analyzing the relationship between quarterback ratings and a team’s record. We compared the top 15 QBs to the bottom half of the NFL’s signal callers, then looked at a team’s record through Week 9.
There were 10 teams with a winning record and had an above average QB: San Francisco (Purdy), Cincinnati (Burrow), Buffalo (Allen), Green Bay (Love), Detroit (Goff), Kansas City (Mahomes), Denver (Nix), Jacksonville (Lawrence), New England (Maye) and the Los Angeles Rams (Stafford). A random model showed that 7.5 cases were expected.
We also found 11 teams had a below-average QB and a losing record: Atlanta (Pennix), Tampa Bay (Mayfield), Washington (Daniels), Baltimore (Jackson), New York Jets (Smith), Arizona (Brissett), Los Angeles Chargers (Herbert), Indianapolis (Jones), Miami (Willis), Tennessee (Ward), and Philadelphia (Hurts). Some of those are good quarterbacks, but were injured this season and missed time. A random model showed that 8.5 cases were expected.
There were six teams with below-average quarterbacks who had winning records: Cleveland (Watson), Pittsburgh (Rodgers), Seattle (Darnold), New York Giants (Winston), Minnesota (Murray) and Chicago (Williams). Again, some of these players have been injured. There were 8.5 such cases expected in a random model.
There were also five teams with losing records and above-average QBs: Dallas (Prescott), Las Vegas (Cousins), Houston (Stroud), Carolina (Young), and New Orleans (Shough). There were 7.5 expected cases generated by a random model.
The Chi-Square Statistic was just shy of the threshold needed to reject the null hypothesis at the 95% level (X2 = 3.137255, p <.10), but it was statistically significant at the .10 level, a lower threshold of confidence.
In other words, we found that the having a good QB was pretty important. It’s not the only factor that guarantees a winning record. But now we see why Minnesota traded for Kirk Cousins, and other teams have been trading for a quarterback. It’s not the only reason for success in the NFL, but an important piece in the equation.
John A. Tures is a professor of political science at LaGrange College in LaGrange, Georgia. His views are his own. He can be reached at jtures@lagrange.edu or on “X” at @johntures2. His first book “Branded” a thriller novel where corporate greed, media manipulation and academic intrigue collide in a deadly game of product placement, has been published by the Huntsville Independent Press (https://www.huntsvilleindependent.com/product-page/branded). His second novel, “Independent Thought,” about a third-party candidacy that brings America to its knees, is also published by HIP (https://www.huntsvilleindependent.com/product-page/independent-thought).
