Smyrna passes non-discrimination ordinance over one council member’s objections

residents at town hall for Smyrna non-discrimination ordinanceSmyrna residence at town hall for non-discrimination ordinance (photo by Haisten Willis)

With one member opposed, the Smyrna City Council passed a long-discussed non-discrimination ordinance on Monday night.

The policy, which passed 6-1 with Corky Welch voting no, is intended to protect “the rights of all people to be free from discrimination or interference with their established civil rights,” and drew dozens of comments during a July 14 town hall meeting.

It sets up a formal complaint process for anyone who feels they are a victim of discrimination, followed by mediation and, potentially, court hearings and a civil penalty for the violator.

“This is an issue that we’ve been talking about for months,” said Smyrna Mayor Derek Norton. “This city government has been very clear that discrimination has no place in the City of Smyrna, and that this is a place that welcomes everyone.”

The ordinance specifically protects against discrimination by race, color, religion, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, marital status, veteran/military status or age if the person is 40 or older.

City attorney Scott Cochran took the lead in writing the language of the ordinance and noted that it had been through numerous changes. He said that churches and private schools are exempt from it, and that it would not allow men to compete on women’s sports teams.

“This is a lot simpler than the ordinances that some other jurisdictions have passed,” Cochran said.

Welch spoke up as soon as council members were allowed to make comments, saying he was fine with everything in the ordinance save for the part about gender identity.

Welch then listed five examples of men being cited or arrested for entering women’s restrooms, in some cases dressed “in drag,” and watching, filming or sexually assaulting the women inside.

“This ordinance is opening a door that we cannot close,” he said. “The end is not tonight’s vote, but down the road when there will be unintended consequences. That’s what we’re facing with the approval of this ordinance with the gender identity clause included.”

Ward 2 councilman Austin Wagner spoke up to rebut Welch.

“We already have laws that cover the situations that (Welch) discussed,” said Wagner. “People going into bathrooms with or without a non-discrimination ordinance to go in to abuse somebody or to engage in any other criminal activity — we already have laws that cover that. This doesn’t make that any easier.”

“Any insinuation, whether intentional or unintentional, that transgender individuals would be more likely to commit these types of crimes, I think that insinuation is inappropriate and not correct.”

Other council members spoke up to voice their support of the ordinance before it was brought to a vote and approved. There was applause in the room after the vote was announced.

Haisten Willis is a freelance writer who lives in Smyrna with his wife, daughter and dog. He holds a master’s degree in journalism from California State University, Fresno, serves on the board of SPJ Georgia and even rides a bike when time allows.

Advertisement

1 Comment on "Smyrna passes non-discrimination ordinance over one council member’s objections"

  1. Clare H Fields | August 4, 2020 at 8:30 am | Reply

    Finally Smyrna is endorsing the civil rights of ALL Americans.
    Kudos for the tenacity.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.