Mount Bethel UMC files counterclaim against North Georgia Conference

photo of Cobb Superior Court building from the front with a blue sky with clouds in the backgroundCobb County Superior Court (photo by Larry Felton Johnson)

Mount Bethel United Methodist Church, which has been in a dispute with the UMC North Georgia Conference that came to a head when the church refused to accept the minister assigned to them in the annual Methodist church assignments, announced in a press release this afternoon that they have filed a counterclaim against the conference.

The conference had filed in Cobb Superior Court to seize the assets of Mount Bethel UMC in early September.

Mount Bethel UMC issued the following press release this afternoon:

MARIETTA, Georgia, Oct. 8, 2021 Mt. Bethel Church today filed its responsive counterclaim and third-party claim in the Superior Court of Cobb County against the North Georgia Conference of the United Methodist Church, its Trustees, Bishop, and District Superintendent (Regional UMC Administrators). The claim asks the Court to require that they permit Mt. Bethel to move forward with a vote to disaffiliate from the UMC as is afforded in the denomination’s Book of Discipline.


Bishop Sue Haupert-Johnson of the North Georgia Conference (NGC) orchestrated a pastoral conflict with Mt. Bethel beginning in April 2021. In response, on April 14, 2021, Mt. Bethel’s Administrative Council voted to begin the disaffiliation process, which has yet to be scheduled by the NGC despite a deadline for its completion.

“If the Regional UMC Administrators really believe the rhetoric they have been spreading—that [Mt. Bethel’s] 50-member Administrative Council unanimous vote was a rogue take-over by a few local church leaders who do not in fact speak for the majority—then, LET THE CHURCH VOTE!,” reads the filing.

Mt. Bethel is a thriving 10,000-member congregation with substantial assets. In addition to blocking the disaffiliation voting process, the NGC has retaliated against the church by proclaiming a sham “closure” and take-over of the local church and its assets, based on the Regional UMC Administrators’ inaccurate and pejorative claim of ‘exigent circumstances.’

Mt. Bethel leadership sought to resolve the issues with the NGC via the processes outlined in the Book of Discipline as well as through civil and church-led mediations, but on Sept. 8, NGC’s Trustees filed a lawsuit against Mt. Bethel intended to punish the church and to intimidate other traditional United Methodist churches in the conference that might also be considering use of the disaffiliation process.

“Despite this action by the Regional UMC Administrators to punish Mt. Bethel, Mt. Bethel continues today to perform ministry in the name of Jesus Christ throughout Metro Atlanta and in places all over the world,” the filing states. “It is sadly ironic that the Regional UMC Administrators accuse Mt. Bethel of violating unwritten ‘conditions of disaffiliation’ while themselves violating the expresstext of the Book of Discipline disaffiliation procedure the General Conference adopted.”

Declaring the NGC is asserting ownership over property in a deliberate effort by the Regional UMC Administrators to dry up Mt. Bethel’s resources by deterring member contributions, Mt. Bethel is seeking immediate injunctive relief from the Cobb County Court.


2 Comments on "Mount Bethel UMC files counterclaim against North Georgia Conference"

  1. Denise Gillette | October 27, 2021 at 9:30 pm | Reply

    Having been married at Mt. Bethel, having been a regular member of Mt. Bethel for 10+ years and having seen the Body of Christ grow spiritually, help tens of thousands of needy people, the kindness and “Jesus hearts” of Mt. Bethel members… it is heartbreaking to hear of the darkness enveloping Mt. Bethel. Yes, we members follow what is written in the Bible and are ready to fight for what is right in God’s eyes and what is Godly and pure. Perfect, we are not but we do strive to respect God’s Word — for which we are paying a very high price, unfortunately.

  2. Christine Baker | November 25, 2021 at 8:43 pm | Reply

    Did Jesus say cannot worship 2 gods one of them being money? And something like it’s easier for a Cammel to go thru an eye of a needle then a rich man getting into heaven- Well if the church closes Jesus said pick any rock and you will find me. HAVE A NICE DAY.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.